Staten Island Neighborhoods > Tottenville

Tottenville Homes For Sale

Tottenville is the southernmost neighborhood of Staten Island with an area of approximately 1.7 square miles. Originally named Bentley Manor by one of its first settlers, Captain Christopher Billop (1638–1726), after a small ship he owned named the Bentley, the district was renamed Tottenville in 1869, apparently in honor of the locally prominent Totten family, whose name can be seen on tombstones in one of the earliest churches, Bethel Methodist Church, on Amboy Road.

Keep on reading below to find out more about Tottenville and the charming real estate that it has to offer.

Browse Tottenville, Staten Island Real Estate

Browse Tottenville, Staten Island Real Estate

17 Properties Found. Page 1 of 1.
Photo of Listing #429182

34 Summit, Staten Island

$1,499,000 - 5 Beds, 6 Baths, 3,850 Sf

MLS® # 429182

Photo of Listing #427889

9 Poe, Staten Island

$1,439,999 - 4 Beds, 3 Baths, 5,148 Sf

MLS® # 427889

Photo of Listing #422508

576 Yetman, Staten Island

$1,149,000 - 4 Beds, 5 Baths, 4,120 Sf

MLS® # 422508

Photo of Listing #427821

107 Bedell, Staten Island

$999,000 - 6 Beds, 5 Baths, 3,250 Sf

MLS® # 427821

Photo of Listing #429424

138 Sprague, Staten Island

$929,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 4,000 Sf

MLS® # 429424

Photo of Listing #430735
New Listing

124 Connecticut, Staten Island

$924,888 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 3,076 Sf

MLS® # 430735

Photo of Listing #426975

119 Yetman, Staten Island

$889,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 2,459 Sf

MLS® # 426975

Photo of Listing #429222

91 Sprague, Staten Island

$869,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 2,327 Sf

MLS® # 429222

Photo of Listing #427636

602 Yetman, Staten Island

$799,000 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,525 Sf

MLS® # 427636

Photo of Listing #429398

419 Main, Staten Island

$760,000 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,185 Sf

MLS® # 429398

Photo of Listing #425587

301 Chelsea, Staten Island

$759,999 - 3 Beds, 5 Baths, 1,500 Sf

MLS® # 425587

Photo of Listing #430430
New Listing

445 Manhattan, Staten Island

$749,999 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,664 Sf

MLS® # 430430

Photo of Listing #427334

5355 Arthur Kill, Staten Island

$739,000 - 8 Beds, 4 Baths, 4,100 Sf

MLS® # 427334

Photo of Listing #429426

8 Massachusetts, Staten Island

$729,999 - 4 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,200 Sf

MLS® # 429426

Photo of Listing #426500

96 Connecticut, Staten Island

$699,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 2,400 Sf

MLS® # 426500

Photo of Listing #429793

370 Main, Staten Island

$599,000 - 3 Beds, 3 Baths, 1,566 Sf

MLS® # 429793

Photo of Listing #428202

244 Barnard, Staten Island

$529,999 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,568 Sf

MLS® # 428202

Register with Casandra Properties

Register today to get the latest in real estate news, as well as instant access to advanced search features that allow you to bookmark properties or even set up alerts for when new ones appear on the market. Don't miss out!

Contact Us Sign Up Today!

Tottenville Real Estate

This historically significant neighborhood is located at the southern end of Staten Island and is less than 25 miles from New York City. Dominated by single-family homes and estates, the real estate in Tottenville has a distinctive Victorian feel. This stunning community was established in the late 1800s and is home to the most impressive Native American burial ground in Staten Island. It’s rich history and affordable prices draw tourists and New York locals in from all over the state. As one of the safest neighborhoods in New York, it’s perfect for single parents, families, and empty nesters.

Tottenville real estate offers a variety of colonial-style homes that were built as far back as the early 1900s. Some homes have expansive waterfront views of Raritan Bay and the surrounding waterways. The neighborhood is encompassed by towering evergreens and gorgeous forests, parks, and green belts. Streets are lined with tall trees and front yards are beautifully crafted by professional landscapers.

Prices vary in Tottenville and typically begin at around $300,000. Luxury home prices begin at closer to $800,000 and go up from there, with the most expensive boasting those waterfront views and more than 4,000 square feet of living space.

New construction has been occurring over the last several years, and Tottenville is expected to see more growth in the future. Despite its average size, it’s surprisingly quiet and lots are comfortably large. Some are even big enough to fit a pool in the back!

For those who have kids, the Bedelle Avenue area is absolutely ideal. Not only is it close to a number of outstanding schools, but it’s also conveniently close to South Shore Little League, Larry De Young Field, Aesop Park, and many other incredible family and kid-friendly places.

Living in Tottenville

Life in Tottenville is as charming as it is exciting. While it is largely residential, there are a number of shops, restaurants, and cafes that are conveniently close and may not even need a vehicle to get to. See just a few of them below:

  • Aloysia’s Lounge
  • Cracker Barrel Deli
  • Villaggio Pizzaria Restaurante
  • Tottenville Food Mart
  • Buds & Blooms Florist

Just outside of Tottenville, you’ll find box stores like Target, The Home Depot, and Ulta Beauty. Also check out the Colonial Rifle & Pistol Club, The Historic Old Bermuda Inn, and South Shore Golf Course; there’s truly something for everyone in this community.

Tottenville is full of greenery and natural spaces. Mountain bike, head out for a hike, or visit a nearby park with the new baby. Hybrid Oak Woods Park is one of the most breathtaking in the neighborhood. Not only will you find peaceful trails and delightful scenery, but you have the option to go right down to the beach. Other parks in the vicinity include Butler Manor Woods, Long Pond Park, and North Mount Loretto State Forest.

To book a home viewing or to discover more about Tottenville real estate, contact Casandra Properties Inc!

Back to Tottenville Real Estate

Listing courtesy of

© 2019 Brooklyn New York MLS. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS or Casandra Properties Inc. Data last updated: June 17th, 2019 at 5:00pm EDT

Sign up for email updates